Share |

NB Housing Authority Stops Issuing “Improper Parking Fines”

After NBToday Exposed Questionable Tickets at February 3 City Council Meeting, NBHA Executive Director John Clarke Took Action
NBHA
The NB Housing Authority is under fire for issuing excessive fines and charges to tenants in the Schwartz-Robeson projects. Charlie Kratovil

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ—The Executive Director of the New Brunswick Housing Authority (NBHA) has ordered his staff to stop issuing "improper parking fines" in the Schwartz Homes and Robeson Village public housing neighborhoods.

"I have directed [Schwartz-Robeson] staff and management to not issue any more improper parking fines until further notice," wrote Executive Director John Clarke in a February 4 email to New Brunswick Today.

The about-face comes one day after NBToday raised concerns about the parking tickets--and other fines residents were reportedly receiving in the public housing neighborhoods--at a City Council meeting.

"I didn't know [about the parking violations] either, until some residents told me about it," said City Councilwoman Rebecca Escobar, a former NBHA Commissioner who is the Council's liason to the authority.  "According to what it says out there, it's allowable. I might not agree with it, but I will find out more information."

The parking fines cost tenants much more than those associated with tickets issued by the New Brunswick Parking Authority (NBPA), and the fines appear to violate the city's ordinances.

The parking fines appear to have been issued by an employee working under the direction of NBHA's property manager Andrea Eato-White, who was curiously appointed to the NBPA's Board of Commissioners last May. 

Clarke was unable to say what year the Housing Authority started issuing the parking violations, or provide an estimate of how many parking violations were issued in 2015.

"I will be meeting with the property manager and the Housing Authority attorney next week to review the [Schwartz-Robeson] parking rules and related policies for that public housing site," Clarke elaborated.

Some residents told us the fine prices can also vary.  Clarke stressed that parking violations were only issued to "repeat offenders."

"The first ticket is 50.00, then it goes up," said one Schwartz Homes resident, who shared others' concern that parking violations were just one form of excessive fines employed by the authority.

"I had to pay for the lights to be replaced, like you mentioned [in NBToday's February 2 article]," the source said.

Council President Kevin Egan, the liason to the NBPA, confirmed that the NBHA rates were out of step with what the Parking Authority charges.

"No, [$50] is high," said Egan.

According to New Brunswick's city ordinances, parking violations are punishable by summonses between $20 and $40, depending on the type of violation.

The ordinances also state that it is legal for anyone to park on both sides of Wright Place between Van Dyke Avenue and Lufberry Avenue, so long as it's not during "alternate side parking" hours or in a space for "handicapped persons."

The following is the schedule of parking fines for everywhere in New Brunswick, including Wright Place:

10.12.060—10.12.070 Loading Zone $30.00
10.12.080 Taxi Stand $20.00
10.12.100 Bus Stop $30.00
10.16.010—10.16.080 Parking Prohibited Area $40.00
10.16.030 Alternate Side Parking $25.00
10.16.050 Parking Exceeding Time Limit $35.00
10.16.090 Snow Removal $30.00
10.16.130 Overnight Parking $30.00
10.16.150 Parking on Private Property $30.00
10.24.080 Meter Feeding $35.00
10.28.010—10.28.080 Permit Parking $27.00

Alleged violators also do not get to challenge the tickets in municipal court, but instead are left with only one recourse: a "grievance" process run by a NBHA employee.

Councilwoman Escobar said she was "asking some questions" but said she hadn't had a chance to talk to officials at the Housing Authority or the Parking Authority.

"I have not called to either John Clarke or the Parking Authority," Escobar said at the public meeting. "But it seems that it is legal, within the right of the Housing Authority to do that."

Escobar did not respond to a request for comment on Clarke's decision to halt the ticketing.

Clarke directed any residents or guests "that believe they were not illegally parked on Housing Authority property and were issued an improper parking fine by the Housing Authority" to file for a "grievance hearing."

"They can file a written request for an informal hearing at the Management Office, 7 Van Dyke Avenue (attn.: Hearing Officer)," said Clarke, "and they will be afforded a hearing."